Feedback in Management – Referring to facts as the basis for feedback.
Regular, honest, and fair feedback is the foundation for awarding bonuses and mapping out career paths. In every enterprise, company, and organization, it is not only the completion of day-to-day tasks that matters, but also interpersonal, communication, and presentation skills. Numerous studies show that the direct relationship between a supervisor and a subordinate, as well as the workplace atmosphere, are key factors influencing employee effectiveness and engagement. The relationship with a supervisor should be based on mutual respect, trust, honesty, and ongoing dialogue regarding work style and the prevailing atmosphere. Equally important are collegial relationships with coworkers. This “shared sense of purpose” is the key to the company’s success and employee satisfaction.
How do you give feedback?
It is important that feedback be based on specific, observable behaviors. Only by relying on observations that are as objective as possible—rather than merely personal opinions—can we influence the work environment and improve individual and team performance.
Regular feedback on work performance, identifying areas where we excel and areas for improvement, is the foundation of a supervisor’s respect for an employee’s value. This approach gives employees a sense of security and opportunities for growth. Recognition and the various forms of rewards that follow (awards, words of appreciation, bonuses, promotions, etc.) contribute to improved work performance and employee loyalty.
What is essential for constructive feedback?
What is key to constructive feedback is observable, specific, and concrete behavior that is a fact (with no room for doubt regarding its interpretation). Behavior refers to a specific action, such as helping and training a new employee, or an omission, such as leaving confidential documents unsecured.
It’s one thing to say, “The employee is irresponsible,” but it’s quite another to say, “The employee has submitted the report late for the third time.” Noting that “The employee helped a colleague with an additional task” sounds much better than writing, “The employee is helpful.”
Consistency in recording is equally crucial, as it is the only way to ensure that the documented behaviors provide a reliable picture of an employee’s actual engagement. Constructive feedback—for example, in the form of a periodic review—based on individual behaviors observed over the course of several months is more likely to be objective. It is important to remember that reliable conclusions cannot be drawn from incomplete or carelessly collected data.
It is important that constructive feedback, based on records or notes of employee behavior, be as fair as possible. The consequences of rewarding someone who does not deserve a reward, or—on the other hand—underestimating genuine commitment and hard work, are easy to predict… This usually results in a sense of injustice and reduced motivation, and often leads to the loss of valuable employees. Everyone wants to be appreciated—if they try hard and no one notices, sooner or later they will stop trying, or they will try elsewhere, with a different employer.
What are the benefits of corrective feedback, and how should it be given?
When a manager identifies areas for improvement, it gives employees a sense of being valued and recognized. Employees are not left to fend for themselves; instead, they feel supported and cared for. In a company, just as in sports, poor performance, acknowledging the problem, naming it, and owning up to it are often prerequisites for positive change and employee growth. Drawing attention to areas requiring development (noting negative behavior in the app) should not create tension, but should be constructive, offering a chance for improvement—and consequently benefiting both the employee and the company.
Discover the WinWinBalance system, which makes giving feedback easy and intuitive!
